Thats when Warwick realized her disappearance was serious. But from the beginning, some listeners took issue with the podcast's characterization of Kristal and the breezy explanation for some of her choices, especially willingly moving away from her now five-year-old daughter, Akasha, who lives with her father and Kristal's ex-boyfriend, Eli. McDonald reported Reisinger missing on July 30, but Saguache County Sheriff Dan Warwick initially concluded Reisinger had just left town of her own accord. Her reporting is mentioned in the NYtimes, Rolling Stone, People and more. In 2019 Catfish John Keenan was arrested and charged with assault with a deadly weapon and possession of meth in Raleigh. Catfish continues to deny having anything to do with her disappearance. Tyler told me that John had lived 280 days of the year in hotel rooms. "We're a community of mixed people and there's bad eggs in there, there's bad eggs. Catfish indirectly admits to being involved in Kristals disappearance. In part II of the series, I did an in-depth investigation into Catfish John Keenan, reporting that he held several women at gunpoint. From the Saguache County Sheriffs Office to podcaster Payne Lindsey, investigators have been trying to solve Reisingers disappearance for more than five years. So what were the biggest rumors going around Crestone about Kristal's disappearance over two years ago? "The two arrests came out of nowhere 12 years later, a complete shock to meobviously, I want the same result for Kristal's case, but there are so many factors that we can't controlall I can do is expose the truth, find new information and hopefully just get people talking again. [She was] really into Native American traditions (and) the nature of raising consciences and living a peaceful life, Guana told Denvers FOX31 News. He is the son of Gap Inc. founders Donald Fisher and Doris F. Fisher . The two eventually broke up, but they happily co-parented Kasha together. Every Tuesday he got his money. And hed use several credit cards his mother had given him. They showed up and spoke with him but wouldnt divulge what he said. Kristal was just one of thousands of "truth seekers" that have descended upon the area, one that has over 15 different spiritual centers, one that doesn't have a strong police presence but definitely has a strong wildlife presence. Robert J. Fisher (brother) William S. Fisher (brother) John Joseph Fisher (born June 1, 1961) is an American businessman. She was extremely distraught, and I said, What is going on? Kristal Reisinger left her daughter with her ex-boyfriend in Denver to find enlightenment in Crestone, Colorado. and our The story received widespread news coverage including on the Dr. Phil show. Reisinger said she would consider McDonalds advice to call the police. john keenan catfish parentshippo attacks human video. But she had no idea Austin was going to kill him. She called me on June 28 and I took care of her for like the next two weeks because I never seen her that scared. The drug supply dries up. Three months later in June he was arrested for heroin and meth possession. And we know it. One night she saw Catfish at the bar and called the police saying her assaulter was there and she wouldnt leave until they came and questioned him. [1][2] Fisher attended Phillips Exeter Academy[3] and Princeton University, where he received a bachelor's degree[1] in 1983. He claimed he was being harassed by listeners of the podcast and people in the town because of all of the allegations made about him on it. ", But was Kristal one of those bad eggs? Discussion of the cases profiled in the podcast "Up and Vanished", For anyone following the Kristal Reisinger series, Catfish was found dead yesterday of a suspected overdose: https://gurumag.com/catfish-john-keenan-found-dead-in-raleigh/. I was only there for like 15 minutes, Austin told me. I think now in Kristal's case, most of the main players are talking, but there;s still a few people hiding out there.". He was dying., Alyssa Horvath told me she and Austin set Catfish up to rob him. He said John made a shot with the powder and then passed out. Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. Another defense he went with was using Kristal's body type. But he also stated that Kristal had come over around his birthday to watch a movie, smoke weed and drink wine. John Keenan was born on 1 January 1784, in County Antrim, Ireland as the son of Keenan and Bridgit. Lots of good energy. He said he wouldnt have overdosed intentionally, nor would he have killed himself. Be Scofield is the author of the new book Hunting Lucifer: One Reporter's Search for Cults and Demons. Fisher is the son of Doris Feigenbaum Fisher and Don Fisher, the co-founders of Gap, Inc., and inherited his fortune from them. -> See our 5-part Kristal Reisinger Series, Hunting Lucifer: One Reporter's Search for Cults and Demons. She was stone cold sober, she told me during an interview. His family also owns a few spiritual centers there," Payne helpfully detailed in episode seven. Allow notifications. McDonald said this mysterious band of criminals was pretty good at hiding who they were. "I would like some money," he said at one point. Everything was beautiful. After the publication of my series on Kristal Reisinger and Catfish John Keenans involvement in her disappearance another woman has come forward alleging he drugged and raped her. He said John then did a line of a powdery substance, which he thinks was Xanax he got off the dark web. Entertainment Television, LLC A Division of NBCUniversal. Alyssa said he later said in a perhaps joking manner that he killed Catfish. And because Tiffany had showered they couldnt do a rape kit. catfish john keenan Retweeted. ", A post shared by Up and Vanished (@upandvanished). "Catfish" John Keenan became famous after his alleged involvement in the death of Kristal Reisinger. "At this point, I personally think the whole drum circle theory to begin with was a rumor that was spread around intentionally to throw everyone off," Payne said in episode seven. Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and more! Marty overdoses at his parents ranch in Moffat. Peloquin said that Kristal Reisinger told him on June 28 she was drugged and raped at Keenans house and that she recognized only two of the many men involved. Cookie Notice He is the owner of Major League Baseball's Oakland Athletics and has stakes in Major League Soccer's San Jose Earthquakes and Scotland's Celtic F.C. The guys who were directly involved in Kristals rape have strong ties in a drug market that goes back and forth directly from Crestone to Denver, he explained. He offered to let the police search his property, as he had no idea where she was. She also told Peloquin that it happened at Catfishs house. On March 29th, 2022 Catfish John was arrested alongside Vincent Paulich. From what I found, they've had varying degrees of friendship, but regardless of who's friends with who, at one time or another, they all ran in the same circle in Crestone, a very small circle.". The hit podcast is attempting to go 2-for-2 when it comes to figuring out what exactly happened in the two cases of missing women host Payne Lindsey and the rest of the Up and Vanished team have taken on since launching in 2016. Catfish's name actually comes up in the 2016 police report after Kristal was reported missing by her landlord on July 30, as a deputy had heard through social media that he was one of the last people to be seen with Kristal. "They were friends and stuff but she really didn't like himbut he definitely was kind of in love with her for a little bit," Crestone Boyfriend alleged in episode five.